The Cavity Factory
About This Spot
Stepping into The Cavity Factory is like being welcomed into a sweet little sanctuary tucked away in Fountain Square. The pace here feels unhurried, inviting you to linger over the warmth of freshly baked treats and the quiet hum of locals savoring their moment of indulgence. It’s not just a cookie shop—it’s a cozy pause, where the air smells faintly of cinnamon and caramelized sugar, setting the stage for a simple but memorable experience.
The atmosphere hums with friendly familiarity, a reflection of both the craft behind the cases and the community that gathers here. There’s an unspoken understanding this spot is worth the wait, especially for the oversized cinnamon rolls that seem almost impossibly rich and soft, made even more irresistible by thoughtful twists like Biscoff cookie butter or fruity pebble toppings that feel playful but never overdone. Cookies rotate regularly, often surprising with seasonal or nostalgic flavors that invite a second or third visit.
What stays with you, beyond the impeccable treats, is the warm human moment—whether it’s a smile from the owner or the shared excitement among patrons who finally snagged their coveted cinnamon roll after a patient wait. There’s a real sense that this place isn’t just about satisfying a sweet tooth but about creating a local experience that feels personal and a little bit special.
In a neighborhood where authenticity means more than just good food, The Cavity Factory stands out as a place that honors the joy in simple pleasures, served generously and with heart.
What’s Available Here
-
Identifies as Black-owned
-
Identifies as women-owned
-
Small Business
-
In-store pick-up
-
In-store shopping
-
Takeaway
-
Delivery
-
Wheelchair-accessible car park
-
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
-
Breakfast
-
Dessert
-
Toilet
-
LGBTQ+ friendly
-
Transgender safe space
-
Quick visit
-
Credit cards
-
Debit cards
-
NFC mobile payments
-
Credit cards
-
Free of charge street parking
-
Free parking lot
Location & Hours
| Monday | 11:30 AM - 08:00 PM | |
| Tuesday | Closed | |
| Wednesday | Closed | |
| Thursday | Closed | |
| Friday | 11:30 AM - 08:00 PM | |
|---|---|---|
| Saturday | 11:30 AM - 08:00 PM | |
| Sunday | 11:30 AM - 08:00 PM |
Tatiana von Slomski 02 Jan 2026
The MOST incredible desserts of all time. Worth the wait. And my most favorite part of Fountain Square! These cookies and cinnamon rolls are the most delicious things I’ve ever eaten. 20/10 would recommend. Wish I could give this business more stars!
Brittany Racine 30 Dec 2025
My daughter and I were just passing through and saw this cute little shop. We literally did not realize how amazing these cookies are that we got. The price is totally worth it. Recommend snickerdoodle chocolate chip and triple brownie! The lady was super nice and informative! These cookies are unbelievably good! Probably some of the best I've ever had!
Nicole Miller 09 Dec 2025
I have been trying to get a cinnamon roll for weeks but the lines have been crazy!! Sign of a great product and business if you ask me! I stopped in after work yesterday and was able to grab 2! The original and biscoff, which were the two I had been wanting. I am not a small woman, and these things took up my WHOLE lap! They are huge!!! They were very good and you can tell the dough was made with love! If you’re debating trying one, just do it and support a young local baker
Courtney Ellis 10 Nov 2025
Finally went to see what the hype was about. I personally am not huge on sugar but I had one anyways. Just supporting the owner as she is killing it. Best of luck . I would never stand in line because I am lame but watch social media for when people say there are no lines
Collin Hendershot 25 Sep 2025
The Cavity Factory has great cookies, and other desserts. Their primary product is a rotating selection of cookies where each is $5. There are often unique or fun flavors and the texture is my favorite part. The owner is very nice and they are adding new creations regularly. This is a great local business to support and I highly recommend giving it a try. I don't think you'll regret supporting this local business and passing on the cookie place with the pink box. Check their Facebook page for current inventory as it is updated regularly.
Alicia Michelle McAvene 25 Sep 2025
I've been following cavity factory since the pink truck days, love love love their cookies, and finally made it to their shop today and tried the cinnamon rolls. I immediately felt nostalgic when I walked in... the smell of Cinnabon but better. The best cinnamon rolls since Cinnabon left Indiana!